|
 |
Quotes Submission Guide
This section is maintained by Tim Norris
The web interface provides a very easy to use and convenient interface
to the IMDb additions system. Please click the button labelled "Update" near
the bottom of every IMDb name/title page to access that interface. This page
describes how to update quotes information directly via e-mail; it also
provides an explanation for the formats generated by the web updates
system.
We recommend all contributors use the web based update system and avoid
the complexities of the direct email interface described below.
The Quotes List, as all of the IMDb, depends on contributions from its
users. If you decide to contribute, the whole Internet thanks you, as
do I; but there are some guidelines that I'd like you to follow which
will make my job easier and will keep the quality of the Quotes List
high. This document describes those guidelines.
- Be accurate, word-for-word, in quotes you submit. This is often
harder than you think. Include the title of the movie and the names
of characters. It minimizes my work load if you submit your entries
in this format:
# Attack of the Bad Dialog, The (1954)
{Nielsen, Leslie@Commander Evans}: What is it with this movie?
{Borgnine, Ernest@Jonesy}: Beats me, skipper.
- Submit suitable quotes; ones which can be appreciated when taken
out of the context of the movies they came from.
- Keep quote lengths reasonable.
- Broadcast television, screenplays, and especially novelizations of
movies are poor sources for authentic quotes.
I'll try to be fair and impartial when incorporating contributions
into the Quotes List; I expect that most submissions will make it in.
Occasionally, though, I'll exercise my prerogative not to include a
suggested quote. Any such decision I make can be explained by these
guidelines, which follow without further ado.
Accuracy and completeness
We want the Quotes List to be authoritative. That means no matter how
much we love a given quote, we can't use it if we're not sure of its
accuracy. Sometimes there is the urge to think, ``Having a slightly
inaccurate version of this awesome quote is better than having no
version of it at all,'' but I don't buy it. The Quotes List is
getting along just fine even though it's missing the vast majority of
Hollywood's classic lines; and I'm gratified whenever I can turn to
the Quotes List and cite something with confidence. In other words,
having no version of a quote is better than having a slightly
inaccurate version.
Title and year
Every quote must include the title of the movie it came from. It's
also helpful to include the year the movie was released; if you don't
supply it, I have to look it up. There are many cases where the same
title was used for two different movies in different years, so
sometimes including the year is the only way for me to know which
movie you mean.
If there's a single quote that was used in multiple movies, attribute
each source that you'd like to see listed; don't just submit something
like this:
[This quote appears in a lot of movies; I think it's originally from
something Mel Brooks did.]
Badges? We don't need no stinkin' badges!
Again, that's an example of what not to do. Here's the right
way to submit that quote:
# Treasure of the Sierra Madre, The (1948)
{Bedoya, Alfonso@Gold Hat}: Badges? We ain't got no badges. We don't
need no badges. I don't have to show you any stinking badges.
Character names
For each speaker, you must supply the character's name and/or the
performer's name. Both pieces of information go in the Quotes List,
and I can usually look up one from the other. In a pinch---i.e., when
you can remember neither the character nor the performer, and you
can't wait to recheck your source---describe the character in your
quote (``the maid hired by Salieri to spy on Mozart'' or ``Julia
Roberts' college friend in The Pelican Brief''). I may
be able to draw on my vast amount of wasted mental capacity to fill in
the character information (``Lorl'' and ``Alice Stark,'' respectively
[both played by Cynthia Nixon]).
Missing and guessed-at words
Which is the correct quote from Casablanca?
- All the gin joints in all the towns in all the world and she walks
into mine.
- All the lousy gin joints in all the towns in all the world, she
walks into mine.
- Of all the gin joints in all the towns in all the world, she has
to walk into mine.
- Of all the gin joints in all the towns in all the world, she walks
into mine.
Can you pick the right version of this Dirty Harry quote?
- Now I'm gonna ask you one question: Do you feel lucky? Well, do
you, punk?
- Now, you're asking yourself one question: ``Do I feel lucky?''
Well, do you, punk?
- Now, you must ask yourself one question: ``Do I feel lucky?''
Well, do you, punk?
- Now, I just wanna ask you one question: Do you feel lucky, punk?
Granted, the differences are subtle, but we're after fanatically
precise wording, here. The human mind is a funny thing: the way it
remembers spoken language is highly associative, as opposed to the
way, say, computers record written language, as a series of literal
words. Because our memories are associative, it's easy to replace one
word with another when recalling an ``exact'' quote. If the meaning
doesn't change---if the recalled quote still occupies the same
associative slot in our minds---the mistake can go completely
undetected.
Nevertheless, we're not revisionists---we don't presume that any
alteration we make can improve the nuggets of verbal art with which
we're concerned---and for purity's sake we care that each quote in the
Quotes List is worded precisely as in the original.
If you're trying to remember a quote and you're not sure of a word,
don't submit a guess. Hold off until you can confirm the correct
wording. At worst, you can send me a quote that might be imprecise,
but you should label it as such, saying, ``I don't remember whether
Leia addresses him as `Darth Vader' or `Lord Vader' in this scene.''
Be as precise about your imprecision as possible. In cases like this,
I will put the quote in a ``holding area'' until I can confirm the
correct wording.
Most often, though, quotes you submit will be from movies I haven't
memorized or haven't even seen, and I'll have to add the quote as-is.
I'm counting on you to help me keep this list accurate. Incidentally,
the correct Casablanca quote is ``Of all the gin joints
in all the towns in all the world, she walks into mine,'' and the
correct Dirty Harry quote is ``Now, you must ask yourself
one question: `Do I feel lucky?' Well, do you, punk?'' Did you guess
right?
Suitability
What makes one or more lines of dialogue from a movie a ``quote''?
You can't take just any random dialogue and enshrine it. Most of it
isn't especially memorable. What is memorable? Obviously,
it's subjective. Here are my thoughts.
Context
I believe that a good movie quote doesn't require much context.
In my experience, there are two schools of thought on this subject.
One of them---the one that includes me---says that what makes a quote
memorable is that it says something interesting which is largely
independent of the context in which it's said. Maybe the quote is an
interesting comment on human nature; maybe it's a hilarious
non-sequitur; maybe the quote itself contains enough context to stand
alone. Here are some examples, with explanations of why I think
they're good. Please forgive the pedantry.
- Lady Marian Fitzwalter: Why, you speak treason!
Sir Robin of Locksley: Fluently.
This is a good context-free quote. It's memorable because in a mere
five words, we sense the outrage of Marian and the audacious wit and
courage of Robin. The setting isn't important, nor is the larger
story, nor is being able to visualize the scene in which this exchange
took place. To put it another way, from now on, thanks to the concise
brilliance of Robin's riposte, if anyone ever said to you, ``Why, you
speak treason!'' you'd want to respond, ``Fluently.'' (If you're like
me, you'd say something unclever and later think, ``Damn, why didn't I
say `Fluently'?'')
- Mr. Miyagi: No such thing, bad student. Only bad teacher.
This happens to be one of my all-time favorite quotes. It's a concise
summing-up of a whole egalitarian philosophy (in which I either
believe or would like to believe, I'm not sure which).
The other school of thought says that memorable movie quotes are those
that evoke the scenes in which they were spoken; that the importance
is the memorability of the scene, not necessarily the words.
Examples:
- Brody: You're gonna need a bigger boat.
This line, from Jaws, was spoken after Brody got his
first clear view of the shark that he, Hooper, and Quint had been
hunting. The scene is certainly among Hollywood's most memorable:
Brody, startled to suddenly find himself scooping ``chum'' right into
the mouth of an unexpectedly enormous and terrifying fish, backs
slowly and rigidly into the cabin of the small fishing boat and calmly
delivers this line to the skipper.
But: What does it mean? Taken out of context---as
IMDb quotes sometimes are---and read, perhaps, by someone who's never
seen Jaws or doesn't remember it, what is the
entertainment value of ``You're gonna need a bigger boat''? The line
can be comic: I can imagine a character saying it to a pleasure-boat
operator when he gets a gander at the crowd lined up at the pier. It
can be sardonic: picture the exec of a battleship which has just
disabled an enemy aircraft carrier, saying this line to his captain as
they start to take prisoners aboard. The point is, it can mean
anything at all. By itself, it's not funny, clever, deep, moving, or
interesting in any other way.
That said, I'll back off a bit and say that this particular quote
is a suitable one because it's a bona fide classic; but that
description applies to a very select set of quotes.
- Kent Gregory: Hey everybody. Drinks are on me.
So what?
Another sign that a quote needs too much context is that it begins
with a lot of narration. A little narration is OK and can aid in the
appreciation of a perfectly memorable quote, such as:
[Lieutenant Gorman orders the troops to unload all their weapons
before the first alien encounter]
Private Frost: What the hell are we supposed to use, man? Harsh
language?
but too much narration turns the quote into a shaggy-dog story:
[The heroes have found the bank with the gold, but there is still one
lone German Tiger Tank to be reckoned with. Supply Sergeant Crapgame
(a notorious hustler) makes the following suggestion to Infantry
Sergeant Big Joe concerning the commander of the Tiger Tank]
Crapgame: Try making a DEAL!
Big Joe: What kind of DEAL?
Crapgame: A DEAL, deal! Maybe he's a Republican. You know, "Business is Business".
In a case like this, the problem isn't that the quote
requires too much narration; it just happens to have
too much at the moment. It can get by just fine with a little less:
[The lone obstacle to the sought-after gold is a solitary tank
guarding the bank.]
Crapgame: Try making a DEAL!
Big Joe: What kind of DEAL?
Crapgame: A DEAL, deal! Maybe he's a Republican. You know,
"Business is Business".
Arguably, this quote would do just fine with no narration at all. But
then there are quotes that just drag too much context around with them
to be appreciated at all:
[When Ace enters a thrash concert and asks a headbanger]
Ace Ventura: Excuse me, can you tell me where Greg is... Thank
you!!!
To be honest, I don't think even this is enough context to justify
this quote. Maybe it would be funny if I had seen Ace Ventura:
Pet Detective, but I haven't (yet) and I just don't see the
point. And finally, this one:
[Benjy Stone and a very drunken Alan Swann are up on a roof as Swann
attempts to shimmy down the side of the building]
Benjy Stone: Let's *not* do this - it's too dangerous!
Alan Swann: Nonsense! It worked perfectly well in "A Slight
Case of Remorse"!
Benjy Stone: That was a movie! This is real life!
Alan Swann: What is the difference?
works even better as a contextless quote, turning it into an ironic
comment suitable for any occasion:
Benjy Stone: That was a movie! This is real life!
Alan Swann: What is the difference?
Tag lines
I'm not a big fan of catchy tag lines with little else to recommend
them as quotes, such as ``Hasta la vista, baby'' or ``Trust me,'' but
I recognize the need to preserve them as something that at least the
studio's PR department thought would be memorable.
Length
``Begin at the beginning,'' the King said, gravely, ``and go on till
you come to the end: then stop.''
-- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
A quote should be exactly as long as it needs to be, no more, no less.
The Quotes List contains very short quotes, very long quotes, and
everything in between. That said, I think long quotes are seldom
worthwhile. (Not never, just seldom.) If you feel the urge to submit
a memorable soliloquy, it's often better to split out the few
memorable sayings contained within the soliloquy into
separate, pithier quotes, rather than keep the whole speech as a
single quote.
Authentication
Many movies can be seen on broadcast television, but in many cases
they're butchered by censors to remove something offensive, or by a
station or network to make a long movie fit in a time slot, or by some
studio hack who figures more people will tune in if they show a
"special television edition" with previously cut scenes
restored. (Personally, when I erase a mistake, I like it to
stay erased.) So if you hear a quote in a broadcast version of a
theatrical release, it may not be the same thing that paying audiences
heard. Naturally, being purists, we're only interested in the
latter.
Some people seem to think that combing through the book version of a
movie is a good way to get accurate quotes from the movie. Not so.
The correlation between movie dialogue and book dialogue is usually
extremely low (sometimes the same is true of the characters and the
plot!). Similarly, even screenplays (such as can be found on the Net
or bought in book or video stores) must be treated with suspicion,
because the final cut of the film may have diverged from whatever
version of the screenplay you have. For the purposes of the Quotes
List, a quote is only authentic if it is a transcript of the spoken
dialogue in the final cut of the film.
Mechanics
This section describes the mechanics of getting your Quotes List
submissions to the Internet Movie Database team, and is identical to
the instructions that can be found in the ASCII version of the Quotes
List.
Here are the instructions specific to the Quotes List.
Additions
- Address a mail message to adds@imdb.com
- In the body of the message, preceding any quotes, include a
line containing the keyword "QUOTES".
- Include the title of the movie and, if possible, the year it
was released. (Many titles have been reused over the years, so if
you say a quote is from "Heaven Can Wait," for example, I may not
know which "Heaven Can Wait" you mean.) If you don't know the
year, include some other distinguishing information; e.g. "The
Michael Keaton Batman (as opposed to the Adam West Batman)". Make
sure that the information really is distinguishing, though; for
instance, it wouldn't be enough to say "The Alfred Hitchcock
version of `The Man Who Knew Too Much.'" There were two of them.
The preferred format for the title information is
# Chorus Line, A (1985)
- Write the quote like a movie script; i.e., with the speaker's
name preceding each line. Include at least one of the performer's
name and the character's name. If you know both, it's easiest on
me if you write it like this: {Last, First@Character}. Example:
{Liotta, Ray@Shoeless Joe Jackson}: Is this heaven?
{Costner, Kevin@Ray Kinsella}: No, it's Iowa.
- Each quote contains one or more lines of dialog. If you're
submitting more than one quote, separate each quote with a blank
line. Example:
# Fletch (1985)
{Matheson, Tim@Alan Stanwyck}: You do own rubber gloves?
{Chase, Chevy@Fletch}: I rent 'em. I have a lease with an option to
buy.
{French, Bruce@Pathologist}: Ever seen a spleen that large?
{Chase, Chevy@Fletch}: No, not since breakfast.
Similarly, if you're submitting quotes from more than one movie,
include the "# Title (Year)" before each movie's block of
quotes.
- Be accurate and complete. If you don't know a quote verbatim,
don't submit it. Don't guess at words or use ellipses to indicate
a section of the quote you don't remember.
- Choose suitable quotes. A quote is suitable if it can be
appreciated out of context, if it isn't overly long, if it's
meaningless but exceptionally classic (like "Play it, Sam"), and
so on. I reserve the right to make all final editorial judgments.
- If the additions include a title that is new to the database,
please also include a section of the form:
TITLE
<title>|<year>|
Example:
TITLE
North by Northwest (1959)|1959|
Silence of the Lambs, The (1990)|1990|
- Mark the end of your data with the word
END
on a separate line.
- Mail the data to adds@imdb.com.
The mail-server will mail a receipt back to you and place the data in
the queue for processing by the list managers in the next update.
Quotes from non-English-language films are accepted, but they
must be in English (ideally, as translated in the subtitles).
Corrections
You can also use the keyword-based mail interface to submit
corrections to existing quotes.
- Address a mail message to adds@imdb.com
- In the body of the message, preceding any corrections, include
a line containing the keyword "CORRECT-QUOTE".
- Include the quote that is in error. You must give the movie
title, year, and text of the quote.
- Write a comment to the effect that the quote is in error, and,
being very specific, describe how to correct the quote. It's
best to include a complete version of the corrected quote. Here's an
example:
CORRECT-QUOTE
# Cool Hand Luke (1967)
Captain: What we have here is a failure to communicate.
This should read,
Captain: What we've got here is failure to communicate.
- Mark the end of your data with the word
END
on a separate line.
- Mail the data to adds@imdb.com.
The mail-server will mail a receipt back to you and place the data in
the queue for processing by the list managers in the next update.
|